How to Start Your College List

mneushul • February 6, 2024

With almost 2,500 colleges and universities in the United States, searching for the right college can seem overwhelming. Here are some suggestions to help you get started and keep it going.


Block out one hour a week and sit in front of the computer or your phone to start looking at colleges. Commit the time and take the first step to get the process moving. Once you have looked at a few colleges, start setting goals on what you want to accomplish during each "college research hour," such as finding a likely school or ranking your preference for match schools. Feel free to start with colleges you have heard older teammates or classmates attend.


I recommend opening a new email address before you start contacting colleges, making college visits, or applying. This will keep everything in one place for easy access. Most colleges don't want you to use an email account from your high school. Frequently, these emails have blocks on them which may prevent you from receiving information. There might also be problems when you graduate or if you change schools midyear. Please consider giving your parents access to your new email so they can help you manage the sheer volume of emails you will start to receive. A Gmail account with your name and graduation year is one suggestion but you can create any time of email address.


There are several websites that can help you get started on your search. Look at the U.S. News Best Colleges Rankings. But be aware that rankings are flawed, to say the least, and several of the factors U.S. New uses simply aren't relevant for a student. But U.S. News provides a starting point to begin your research. Use each ranking to start your own college research. There are also other college rankings you can look at, such as the Princeton Review Best Colleges and Niche College Rankings. The U.S. News rankings break up the colleges by type, which allows you to consider the kind of colleges you prefer. Do you want to attend a school with name recognition, a big state flagship university, a private college, or a small liberal arts college? 


The U.S. News rankings also provide a relatively comprehensive directory of colleges with basic descriptions and admission statistics. However, I want to caution you about the descriptions and statistics on the U.S. News site (and other similar sites), as they may not be up-to-date. Always check the college websites directly for the most up-to-date information about admission requirements, academic and other student programs, and tuition.


Once you have a list of potential colleges you may be interested in attending (remember that you need a decent number of target and likely schools in addition to your reach), it's time to dig deeper. Learn about the colleges from students who are already there by browsing resources such as Niche and sites like BigFuture from The College Board.

If you have specific questions about admission requirements, major requirements, financial aid, or scholarships, contact the college's appropriate office for clarification. The admissions office may have students or clerical staff answering the phone for most colleges. Expect to get conflicting information every now so ask for an admission officer if you have particular questions about admission requirements. 


Your college application process can only begin when you sit down and look at colleges that might be a good fit for you. The sooner you do that, the more time you have to gather information about each school and the better prepared you will be so you know where to apply in the Fall.


By MaryMichael Neushul • October 5, 2026
Why should students take the PSAT?
By MaryMichael Neushul • October 5, 2026
Intellectual Curiosity: Why do Colleges want to see it and How do students show it?
By MaryMichael Neushul • August 16, 2026
Back to School: A Grade-by-Grade Guide for Mater Dei, Newport Harbor & Corona del Mar Students
By MaryMichael Neushul • July 7, 2026
Your Summer Checklist Before Senior Year Begins Summer feels like a break, and it should be. But if you're heading into senior year this fall, there are a few things worth tackling before mid-August. Getting these done now means less stress once school starts and applications are due. Here's what to focus on. 1. Open Your Common App Account The Common App is already open for rising seniors, and the profile page is the easiest part to knock out early. It's mostly basic information: your contact details, family information, education history, and testing. Getting this done now clears the way for the harder parts later. 2. Build Your Resume, Then Use It to Complete the Activities Section Before you touch the Activities section of the Common App, sit down and build a full resume. List every activity, job, leadership role, and commitment from the last four years, along with your actual time investment and what you accomplished. Once that's on paper, translating it into the Common App's activities format is much easier, and you're less likely to leave something out or undersell what you did. 3. Brainstorm for Your Personal Statement and Start a draft Your grades and test scores already tell admissions officers a lot about you. Your personal statement is your chance to share what those numbers can't. Spend some time this summer thinking about what you want an admissions officer to know about you that isn't anywhere else in your application. I recommend having a final draft completed before you head back to school. Supplemental essays for most colleges come out August 1, and you'll want that time to focus on them instead of still wrestling with your personal statement. 4. Open a STARS Account and Enter Your Grades STARS (Self-Reported Transcript and Academic System) is required by a number of schools, including Clemson, NYU, and the University of Tennessee, and it's due when your application is due. It's an easy step to forget, and every year students miss it simply because they didn't know it existed. Open your account now and start entering your grades so this isn't a last-minute scramble in the fall. 5. Complete Your Counselor Packet or Brag Sheet Your counselor packet, sometimes called a brag sheet, gives your counselor what they need to write your letter of recommendation. Getting this done over the summer means it's ready to go the moment you're back at school, instead of competing with the first weeks of senior year for your attention.  None of these tasks take a huge amount of time on their own, but knocking them out now means you'll walk into senior year ahead instead of behind. Future you will be grateful.
By MaryMichael Neushul • June 10, 2026
Before your student falls in love with a college online, visit in person. A Newport Beach college counselor shares what 130 campus visits have taught her.
By MaryMichael Neushul • June 8, 2026
What should your student do this summer? A Newport Beach college counselor shares the academic, entrepreneurial, and service activities colleges love to see.
By MaryMichael Neushul • May 12, 2026
Choosing a College Major in the Age of AI What Parents of High School Students Need to Know Right Now
By MaryMichael Neushul • April 21, 2026
UC Admissions from a Newport Beach College Counselor: Behind the Veil
By MaryMichael Neushul • April 6, 2026
Five Things to Do When You are WAITLISTED!
By MaryMichael Neushul • April 1, 2026
Why Spring of Sophomore Year Matters More than You Think!